Aroma visualization from community tastings
Vagabond Spirits New Yarmouth Silva Collection 2005
Poured neat, this is New Yarmouth funk with the volume dialed back a touch. The lower ABV makes it creamy and easy, with overripe pineapple, esters, glue and a maple-cask sweetness folded in. Several tasters caught the salty-sweet play and toasted coconut. A few blind-tasted it and thought Hampden. One caveat: a couple found the maple pushed it "manchmal deutlich zu viel" on sweetness.
The community says- Overripe tropical fruit
- Creamy, well-integrated
- Maple can oversweeten
View price history
+10Secure payment Sold by Rhumlicious Returns & cancellation
- Secure payment. You pay via RumX with PayPal, Klarna or card. Your payment data is encrypted and we never store your full card details.
- Clear seller. Sold and shipped directly by the partner shop. And you're never on your own: RumX handles support and communication with the shop, so you always get excellent service, whichever shop you order from.
- Honest shop ratings. The stars show your service experience with the shop, not the rum score. They come from RumX users, and critical ones stay visible.
- Returns & cancellation. Your purchase contract is with the shop, so returns and cancellations run through them under their own policy and your statutory rights. If anything goes wrong, RumX helps you sort it out.
Buy Vagabond Spirits New Yarmouth Silva Collection 2005:
Compare all 3 shop offers from 176.04 €
Prices & availability last updated on
The look inside the bottle
How does Vagabond Spirits New Yarmouth Silva Collection 2005 taste?
Aggregated from 66 community reviews.
Creamy, fruity New Yarmouth with maple sweetness People genuinely love this one — juicy tropical fruit, well-integrated alcohol, a "sehr süffig" NY. A few felt the maple finish or a late bitter edge tips it a bit far.
Jamaican funk fans who want ester-heavy fruit without full-throttle intensity
Anyone chasing the rawest, driest New Yarmouth or avoiding sweetness
How the community classifies this rum. Each category takes you to similar rums.
35 of 66 left detailed tasting impressions · Click an aroma to explore similar rums
How is Vagabond Spirits New Yarmouth Silva Collection 2005 rated?
RumX’s 0–10 scale is strict: 8.6 sits in the “Very good” band. 100% of tasters rate it Good or better; only 0% rate it below average. See the full rating guide →
Live auctions
Current bids for this rum at Europe's leading auction houses.
Community voices
What does the community say?
6% rate it between 6 and 8. 20 selected write-ups from 66 community ratings. You can view the complete list in our app.
Review by LukaŽiga
8,5:On the nose, the first impression we get are esters, overripe tropical fruits like pineapple, roasted, spicy wood with pastry, cookie dough, there is citrus, some solvents. A molasses is vegetal after airing the rum, as there are notes of vinegar and coconut. 8,7:On the palate, the attack is very tasty with very ripe, estery tropical fruits like pineapple, banana, kiwi, some citrus, later toasted coconut. We might think of tasting some marmelade, perhaps fruitcake.Some dried figs and prunes add to that feeling.Strong honey balances salty, spicy notes, as the wood is roasted with nuts, pastry.The molasses is floral with an elderflower and vegetal with an olive. 8,5:The finish is long, dry with notes from the palate lingering on, just a bit more vinegar tannic, imbalancing the impression in the end and earthy.
Review by Tschusikowsky
Beautifully creamy and harmonious. Compared to the previous bottlings I have had from this vintage, it is less intense due to the reduced ABV. The citrus notes are much more subtle but delicious. The balance is wonderful. The bottling does nothing wrong, very tasty.
Review by RumTaTa
I have two exciting rums in my glass today: this one and, for comparison, RX8199, better known as Vidya the River Mumma. There is hardly any difference in color, the Vagabond is perhaps a touch darker. Nose: very similar to the River Mumma but more subtle and much less intense. Also more emphasis on fruit and less glue and nail polish. The dilution is noticeable in direct comparison and therefore the Vagabond is not as funky. Palate: fruit, esters, olives,... River Mumma with the handbrake on. This is not meant to be derogatory and mainly relates to the alcohol and funk. A bitter note and a dry/salty mouthfeel are noticeable. I also find the bitter/salty note in the River Mumma - but more intense. Finish: the bitter/dry note disappears and gives way to sweet, ripe tropical fruit, which lingers for a very long time. Excellent New Yarmouth, full broadside Jamaica, more accessible, more drinkable and less edgy than RX8199. The dilution is noticeable in direct comparison but the profile is very similar. I particularly like the fact that the fruit is more in the foreground. I rated the River Mumma 9.1, this one is no worse and no better, it just has a different effect because of the dilution, also 9.1
Review by crazyforgoodbooze
Very tasty 2005 New Yarmouth that is basically on par with its younger sister casks. A direct comparison is still pending. The few extra years in the barrel have added a bit more saltiness, but also a bit more acidity (lime). Slightly bitter like roasted walnuts used in Christmas cookies. The typical cookie dough aroma is there too, though not as dominant and a bit toastier than the younger predecessors. Really surprisingly good stuff!
Review by Serge
Delicious New Yarmouth ... very sweet on the nose and palate. There is a pleasant bitter note on the palate, as well as some saltiness and decadent cookies. A nice counter note to the sweetness. Alcohol is very well integrated.
Review by Thunderbird
This is a good solid New Yarmouth. The slight dilution suits it well. While the nose still has clear fruit aromas, they are only fleetingly perceptible on the palate. The sweetness with young wood and a little olive predominates. The alcohol is perfectly integrated. Beautiful sipper
Review by Skyfly
Genau mein Ding, aber das scheint ja jeder 2005er NY zu sein. Dieser überzeugt durch eine gewisse Cremigkeit. Die Verdünnung schadet ihm keineswegs. Lediglich der Abgang ist nicht so lang wie gewohnt.
Review by Eric Frechin
Voilà une très belle découverte. C est la première fois que je goûte un rhum de cette distillerie et ça me donne vraiment envie d en connaître d autres. Globalement très bienéquilibré, ses points forts sont des fruits tropicaux très mûrs, un peu de saumure, du coco torréfié, très légère acidité. Une jolie complexité plutôt facile à boire.
Review by Jakob
Ausgezeichneter New Yarmouth. Das Maple Cask Finish addiert wie zu erwarten schwere Süsse zum Profil, ohne selbiges zu überlagern. Die Fruchtester prägen weiterhin das Bild und überzeugen mit ausdrucksstarker, fruchtiger Frische, die mit dem Ahornsirup im Abgang verschmilzt. Toller Rum.
Review by cigares
German Rum Festival 2025, Berlin. Un nez expressif, presque agressif, avec pas mal d’esters, des fruits tropicaux trop mûrs, des solvants, de la colle et du végétal fermenté. La bouche est très jamaïcaine, raisins au rhum et les esters sont moins marqués, les fruits tropicaux sont un peu plus frais. Le bois est en soutient. La finale est équilibrée, longue, sur les fruits tropicaux. Une belle sélection de fût, j’aime un peu moins le côté agressif et (trop) expressif du nez.
Review by Kevin Sorensen 🇩🇰
#5618 31.08.2025 Tasting at the German Rum Fest 2025. Wow, this was another stunning rum at the Vagabond stand. Super fruity and well balanced ABV. Lots of overripe fruits with a little citrus and some esters. Balance ie really good and there is a nice natural sweetness to it. At the finish there is light nutts and some marzipan.
Review by SaibotZtar
Excellent New Yarmouth nose Ester , pastry, marzipan tropical fruits and some sea breeze .... Very harmonious and balanced in the mouth... Wonderfully fruity funky and always this touch of marzipan pastry and salt crust Very tasty
Review by Vincent D
Quel nez ! J'aurais misé sur un Hampden tant les marqueurs pointent vers cette distillerie. C'est superbe. Et ça donne très envie de goûter. En bouche, ça ne déçoit pas. L'alcool est superbement intégré. C'est à la fois suave, elegant et puissant et racé. Complexe, une touche salée, de la rondeur, des fruits mûrs. Superbe. Belle longueur. Un superbe rhum. Magnifique. Edit : première impression totalement confirmée. Superbe sélection.
Review by Mirco
Ein harmonischer New Yarmouth mit cremiger Textur und ausgewogener Aromatik. In der Nase zeigen sich subtile Ester, begleitet von tropischen Früchten, Zitrusnoten und einem Hauch von Honig. Am Gaumen entfalten sich Nuancen von Trockenfrüchten, Gewürzen und einer leichten Salzigkeit. Im Vergleich zu anderen 2005er Abfüllungen weniger intensiv, dafür zugänglicher und angenehm zu trinken.
Review by Louis Zimmermann
Une découverte réussie pour ce New Yarmouth : un rhum qui séduit par son équilibre et sa gourmandise. Pas dans la démesure jamaïcaine, mais dans une harmonie élégante entre fruits tropicaux mûrs, pâtisserie, noix de coco grillée et fines touches d’agrumes. Une dégustation raffinée et parfaitement maîtrisée par Vagabond Spirits.
Review by Banana Joe
Gefällt mir sehr gut. Sehr harmonisch. Schönes Wechselspiel zwischen salzig und süß. Ein bisschen wie Salzzitronenkekse mit tropischem Fruchttopping. Alkohol sehr gut integriert, die 56% merkt man gar nicht. Jetzt überlege ich, ob ich nicht doch eine Flasche holen soll.
Review by TheJackDrop
Description issue de mon blog : Nez : à peine le sample ouvert, toute la pièce change d’odeur. C’est vraiment dingue ce qu’on peut faire en Jamaïque ! Je suis bluffé à chaque fois, j’espère que cette magie ne s’arrêtera pas de sitôt. 700 gr/hlAA d’esters qui se font sentir, bien sur, mais aussi des fruits bien pourris, une compôtée de mangue, des notes presque mielleuses qui me font penser à du propolis. Derrière, de légères notes camphrées, ou alors ça bien des fruits très mûrs. Les attentes après un tel nez sont assez hautes, espérons que ça continue ! Bouche : superbe, ample, chaleureuse. La papaye domine, les esters se fondent un peu dans le décor… car un côté miel, caramel, cacahuète, sirop d’érable (surement le finish) bien gras amènent un côté pâtissier, viennent les dompter. Finale : quasi infinie, tout est là pour passer un grand moment. Les fruits, les notes gourmandes d’érable, peut être un peu de noix fraiches ou d’amandes… 19 ans de vieillissement au calme qui ont fait maturer un très bon jus, ça valait le coup d’attendre !
Review by zabo
Nachdem ich schon das Sample ewig bei mir daheim rumstehen habe und vor mir her schieben, hab ich diesen am GRF probiert aus Neugier und Fomo. Sehr guter 2005er New Yarmouth, wobei mir die CDI und der S.B.S aus dem Gedächtnis besser gefallen haben.
Review by Master P
Im Vergleich zu anderen NY sehr hell, aber aus dem Glas strömt gleich jamaica funk raus. Ester, gelbe früchte und eine leichte honignote. Geschmsck ist sehr mild und zugänglich. Nach paar Sekunden kommt dann die angenehme süße zurück. Abgang ist top, sehr süffig. Bin überrascht wie gut er schmeckt.
Review by Christian Rudt
Schön balancierte Aromen mit Backgewürz, tropischen Früchten und und einer kleinen Ladung Ester. Am Gaumen mit ordentlich Holz aus der langen Lagerung dazu eine tolle Ananas-Kokos Note. ABV für mich gut getroffen. Einfach lecker 😋
No reviews match this filter.
Expert reviews
Reviews from RumX's blog partners, independent experts who have tasted, evaluated, and described this rum..
Expert review by L'amateur éclairé
Read full review →
Details about Vagabond Spirits New Yarmouth Silva Collection 2005
A rum from Jamaica, bottled by Vagabond Spirits, at 55,8%.
Community purchases
21 bottles logged by 17 collectors.
A collector's bottle.
14% opened, 1 emptied and repurchased.
What does Vagabond Spirits New Yarmouth Silva Collection 2005 cost?
Community paid 147–179 €.
Current best price: 176.04 € – within the typical community range.
What members actually paid for their bottles. A typical range, not the current shop price. Full price & collection history in RX+ →
21 purchased · 67 tasted · 14 wishlist · as of
About the New Yarmouth distillery
The New Yarmouth distillery is located in Jamaica. Rums from New Yarmouth have been reviewed 3,402 times with an average of 8.7/10.
To New Yarmouth →You may also enjoy
Rum enthusiasts who like this rum have also given the following rums high ratings:
Corman Collins CRHUM Verytresbon Blend (CRHUM x Le Blog à Roger) 2025
Corman Collins CRHUM Verytresbon Blend (CRHUM x Le Blog à Roger) 2025Easy, fruity Jamaican blend, gently funky
CDI New Yarmouth Jamaica (Bottled for Denmark) 2009
CDI New Yarmouth Jamaica (Bottled for Denmark) 2009Fruity, estery cask-strength Jamaican funk
Nobilis Hampden No. 46 HD (13. German Rum Festival) <>H 2014
Nobilis Hampden No. 46 HD (13. German Rum Festival) <>H 2014Classic Hampden funk, hot and familiar
Hampden Flensburg Rum Company The Bottle Shop <>H 2014
Hampden Flensburg Rum Company The Bottle Shop <>H 2014Funky cask-strength Hampden, pineapple and glue
Hampden Flensburg Rum Company Exclusive for The Bottle Shop Heilbronn <>H 2019
Hampden Flensburg Rum Company Exclusive for The Bottle Shop Heilbronn <>H 2019Fierce young Hampden funk, sherry-touched
The Wild Parrot New Yarmouth NY Distillery (Special Edition for Corman Collins) 2009
The Wild Parrot New Yarmouth NY Distillery (Special Edition for Corman Collins) 2009Wild, woody New Yarmouth with cookie-dough sweetness
Never miss a price drop.
Set a target price in the app, and we'll let you know as soon as the rum becomes available at that price from one of our partner stores. This works for any rum on your wish list.
Oliver · FounderBy rum lovers, for rum lovers
I'm Oliver, and RumX began in 2018 as a small passion project in Stuttgart, back then under the name Rum Tasting Notes.
What began as my digital tasting diary is now the world's most comprehensive platform for rum fans, today carried by a small team with Jakob, Lukas and Katharina, with Robert supporting us as a freelancer. We combine the collective intelligence of our community with an integrated marketplace, so you can choose with confidence, without paperwork, detours, or expert jargon.
Oliver, Stuttgart
About RumX →
